Matthew 5, the Law âFulfilled,â and the Question Hebrew Roots Teachers Keep Asking
How to Use This Post
This resource is written in a three-tier format so you can read at the depth you need: A Quick Look gives the bottom line, A Simple Explanation walks through the core argument step-by-step, and A Deeper Look addresses Matthew 5, âfulfillment,â Acts 15, and the new covenant with more detail.
Use the Table of Contents to jump to the section that helps you most.
Table of Contents
Bottom Line: NoâJesus did not command feast observance for the church.
Hebrew Roots / Torah-keeping teachers often argue that Matthew 5:17â20 proves Christians must keep the feasts because Jesus said He did not come to âabolish the Law.â But that conclusion doesnât follow from the text.
- Jesus fulfilled the LawâHe brought it to its intended goal in His person and work.
- The New Testament never commands Gentile believers to keep Israelâs feast calendar as covenant obligation.
- The apostles settled the question in Acts 15: Gentiles are not placed under the Law of Moses.
- Christians may observe days as a matter of conscience (Rom 14), but not as a requirement of salvation or covenant faithfulness.
In short: Jesus didnât âcancelâ the LawâHe completed it. And the new covenant people of God live under the Law of Christ, not the Sinai calendar.
The Coffee Mug, Matthew 5, and the Question Behind the Question
I saw a post on my Facebook feed recently from a prominent Hebrew Roots teacher. It was a photo of a friendâs coffee mug. The mug had a picture of Jesus and the words: âOMG You Guys, Thatâs Not What I Said.â
The point was obvious: many Christians claim the feasts and Torah obligations no longer bind believersâand the post implied Jesus would respond, âThatâs not what I said.â Then, as often happens, the conversation went straight to Matthew 5. âSee?â theyâll say. âJesus didnât abolish the Law. Therefore, Christians must keep the feasts.â
Hereâs the issue: the argument skips steps. It assumes that ânot abolishâ means âcontinue every Mosaic command in the same covenant form.â But Jesus didnât say, âNothing changes.â He said He came to fulfill.
1) What Jesus Actually Said
Jesus said He did not come to abolish the Law or the Prophets, but to fulfill them (Matt 5:17). Fulfill doesnât mean âignore.â But it also doesnât mean âfreeze everything in place forever.â In Matthew, âfulfillâ consistently means bring to completion what Scripture anticipated.
2) Jesusâ Teaching in Matthew 5 Moves the Focus to the Heart
Right after Matthew 5:17, Jesus gives a series of examples: anger, lust, truthfulness, retaliation, love for enemies (Matt 5:21â48). Notice what He emphasizes: the heart-level righteousness the Law was always aiming at.
If Matthew 5 were primarily a âfeast-observance mandate,â weâd expect Jesus to say: âTherefore, keep the feasts,â âTherefore, keep the calendar,â or âTherefore, keep Sabbath as covenant requirement.â But thatâs not where Jesus goes.
3) The Apostles Answered the âGentiles + Torahâ Question Clearly
If Jesus intended the feasts as covenant obligation for His followers, the apostles would have taught that plainlyâ especially when Gentiles began coming to Christ in large numbers.
That moment arrives in Acts 15. The question was direct: âMust Gentile believers be circumcised and required to keep the Law of Moses?â (Acts 15:5). The apostolic answerâafter debate, testimony, and Scriptureâwas no. They did not put Gentiles under Sinai.
4) So What About Feasts Today?
Christians may choose to learn from the feasts, study their symbolism, even host Christ-centered meals that point to the gospel. But the New Testament treats âdaysâ as a matter of conscienceânot a salvation issue (Rom 14:5â6; Col 2:16â17).
Pastoral clarity: if a teacher tells believers they are âless faithfulâ unless they keep the feasts, thatâs not ârecovering obedience.â Thatâs placing consciences under a yoke the apostles refused to place on Gentiles.
A Biblical Case: Fulfillment, Covenant, and the âFeasts Required?â Question
1) The Core Mistake: Treating âNot Abolishâ as âNothing Changesâ
Hebrew Roots arguments often treat Matthew 5:17 as if Jesus said, âEverything in the Law continues unchanged as covenant obligation.â But Jesusâ words are more precise: He came to fulfill.
In Matthewâs Gospel, fulfillment language repeatedly signals that the earlier stage of Godâs plan has reached its intended goal in Christ. The shadows were not meaninglessâthey were prophetic. But when the reality arrives, we do not relate to the shadow as though the substance never came.
2) âUntil All Is Accomplishedâ: Fulfillment Has a Finish Line
Jesus adds: âUntil heaven and earth pass away⊠until all is accomplishedâ (Matt 5:18). The New Testament repeatedly describes Jesusâ mission as accomplishing what the Law anticipated: He is the true Lamb, the true Priest, the true Temple, and the mediator of the new covenant.
This is why the New Testament speaks the way it does about covenant transition (Heb 8:13) and about the Lawâs temporary guardian role (Gal 3:23â25). Fulfillment doesnât erase Godâs Wordâit establishes it by bringing it to its intended end in Christ.
3) Matthew 5 Emphasizes the Righteousness the Law Aimed At
The âYou have heard⊠but I say to youâ section doesnât function like a Torah-keeping recruitment speech. It functions like a kingdom proclamation: the Messiah presses beyond external compliance into heart-level obedience.
Thatâs significant because feast observance in Torah is an identity marker for covenant Israelâreal, meaningful, and God-given for that covenant. But Jesusâ emphasis in Matthew 5 is not âkeep Israelâs calendar to prove covenant membership.â It is âlive the righteousness of the kingdom because the King has come.â
4) Acts 15 Is the Apostolic Interpretation of the Question
Acts 15 is not a side topicâitâs the churchâs watershed moment on whether Gentiles must take on the Law of Moses as covenant obligation. The demand was explicit (Acts 15:5). The apostles refused to place that yoke on Gentiles.
If feast observance were required for all followers of Jesus, Acts 15 would have been the place to say it plainly. Instead, the apostles distinguished between: salvation by grace and cultural/mission wisdom for table fellowship and unity.
5) Paulâs Categories: Shadow vs. Substance, Conscience vs. Command
Paul warns against binding consciences with calendar obligations (Gal 4:10â11), and he tells believers not to let anyone pass judgment regarding festival, new moon, or Sabbathâbecause these are shadows, while Christ is the substance (Col 2:16â17).
In Romans 14, Paulâs pastoral framework is even clearer: some regard one day above another; others regard all days alike. The issue is not âWho is disobedient?â but âWho is honoring the Lord with a clear conscience?â
6) Pastoral Summary: What You Can Say With Clarity
- Yes, Jesus honored the Law and fulfilled it.
- No, Jesus did not command feast observance as a binding covenant obligation for the church.
- Yes, the feasts powerfully proclaim Christâand can be taught as gospel-rich shadows.
- No, you may not bind another believerâs conscience where the apostles refused to bind it.
- Yes, the Christian life has a law: the Law of ChristâSpirit-empowered love and obedience flowing from the new covenant.
If someone says, âJesus never said we could stop,â the best response is: Jesus said He came to fulfillâand the apostles show us what that fulfillment means for Gentiles under the new covenant.
Footnotes & Sources
- Matthewâs âfulfillâ theme: see Matt 1:22; 2:15; 4:14; 8:17 and the broader Matthean use of ÏληÏÏÏ (fulfill).
- Galatians 4:4â5 (Christ born under the Law); see also Hebrews 8:13 for covenant obsolescence in light of the new covenant.
- R.L. Solberg, Torahism: Are Christians Required to Keep the Law of Moses? (Gospel Grace Publishing, 2018), esp. the chapters addressing Matthew 5, Acts 15, and the Lawâs covenant function.
- Acts 15:1â29 (Gentiles not placed under the Law of Moses as covenant requirement).
- Galatians 4:10â11; Colossians 2:16â17; Romans 14:5â6 (days treated as shadow/conscience, not covenant obligation).
- For broader evangelical treatments: Thomas R. Schreiner, 40 Questions About Christians and the Law (Kregel, 2010); D.A. Carson (ed.), From Sabbath to Lordâs Day (Zondervan, 1982).
Note: This post is a blog adaptation of Chapter 21 from our Movement D section and is intended to provide clear, Scripture-forward answers with pastoral care and conviction.
Next Up in Movement D
Weâll follow this question into the book of Acts: Did the apostles keep the feasts as covenant obligationâor as mission strategy?
Leave a Reply