How to Use This Commentary
Matthew 5:38–42 continues Jesus’ teaching on true righteousness following Matthew 5:33–37, moving from truthfulness to how we respond when wronged.
Read it in two movements: (1) the misuse of “eye for an eye,” and (2) Jesus’ call to radical non-retaliation and generosity.
Key: Jesus is not removing justice—He is removing personal vengeance.
Our world runs on one instinct:
👉 “If you hurt me, I’ll hurt you back.”
Maybe not physically—
but through words… distance… bitterness… retaliation.
We defend our rights.
We protect our image.
We demand fairness.
But Jesus says:
👉 “That’s not how my Kingdom works.”
Instead of retaliation—
He calls for surrender, trust, and radical grace.
A Quick Look: Matthew 5:38–42
Big idea: Jesus calls His followers to give up personal retaliation and respond to wrongs with humility, generosity, and trust in God.
Why this matters: Our natural response is revenge—but Jesus calls us to reflect God’s grace instead.
Key truth: Justice belongs to God; our role is to live with surrendered hearts.
Bottom line: Kingdom people don’t fight for their rights—they entrust them to God.
A Simple Explanation (Matthew 5:38–42)
“An eye for an eye…” (v.38)
This was a law about justice.
Meaning: Punishment should match the crime.
Problem: People used it to justify personal revenge.
“Do not resist the one who is evil…” (v.39)
Jesus corrects the misuse.
Meaning: Don’t seek personal retaliation.
Application: You are not called to get even.
“Turn the other cheek…”
This refers to insults and personal offense.
Meaning: Don’t respond with revenge.
Application: Choose humility over retaliation.
“Give your cloak also…”
This addresses personal loss.
Meaning: Be willing to surrender more than required.
Application: Value peace over possessions.
“Go the extra mile…”
This refers to forced service.
Meaning: Respond with willingness, not resentment.
Application: Do more than expected.
“Give to the one who asks…”
This addresses generosity.
Meaning: Be open-handed toward others.
Application: Live with a giving heart.
Bridge: Jesus is not calling us to weakness—He is calling us to radical trust in God.
A Deeper Dive: Rights, Revenge, and Kingdom Living
1) The Original Meaning of “Eye for an Eye”
The Old Testament law (Ex. 21:24; Lev. 24:20; Deut. 19:21) established a principle of justice—punishment should fit the crime.
👉 It was meant to:
- Prevent excessive punishment
- Limit revenge
- Protect society
Insight: It was a law for courts—not individuals.
2) The Distortion: From Justice to Personal Revenge
By Jesus’ day, people had turned this law into a personal license for retaliation.
👉 “You hurt me—I’ll hurt you.”
Insight: What was meant to restrain revenge became justification for it.
3) “Do Not Resist…” — What It Means
The Greek word implies resisting with retaliation.
Jesus is not saying:
- Ignore evil
- Allow injustice in society
He is saying:
👉 Do not take personal revenge.
4) Four Examples of Surrendered Rights
Dignity → “Turn the other cheek”
A slap was an insult, not assault.
👉 Don’t retaliate when personally insulted.
Security → “Give your cloak”
Be willing to lose more than required.
👉 Don’t cling to personal rights.
Liberty → “Go the extra mile”
Roman soldiers could force labor.
👉 Respond with willing service.
Property → “Give to the one who asks”
Live generously.
👉 Don’t be ruled by possessions.
Insight: Jesus targets the things we naturally defend most—our pride, possessions, freedom, and comfort.
5) This Is Not Passive Weakness
Jesus is not calling for:
- Lawlessness
- Injustice
- Abuse tolerance
Scripture still affirms:
- Government restrains evil (Romans 13)
- Church discipline addresses sin
- Believers confront wrongdoing when necessary
👉 The focus here is personal retaliation—not public justice.
6) The Real Issue: Self
At the core of retaliation is self:
- My rights
- My reputation
- My fairness
Insight: Retaliation reveals that self is still on the throne.
7) The Call: Die to Self
Jesus is calling His followers to a different posture:
👉 Not self-protection 👉 Not self-assertion 👉 But self-surrender
8) The Example: Jesus Himself
Jesus lived this perfectly:
- He was insulted—but did not retaliate
- He was beaten—but did not respond with vengeance
- He was crucified—but prayed for His enemies
👉 He entrusted Himself to the Father.
9) The Gospel Connection
This passage exposes how far we are from God’s standard.
We want revenge.
We defend ourselves.
We hold grudges.
But Jesus:
👉 Absorbed wrong instead of returning it 👉 Took judgment instead of giving it
Through Him:
👉 We are forgiven 👉 We are changed 👉 We can live differently
- “Eye for an eye” was about justice, not revenge
- Jesus forbids personal retaliation
- He calls for surrender of personal rights
- Kingdom people trust God instead of seeking revenge
- Jesus models and empowers this kind of life
Bottom Line (Matthew 5:38–42)
Jesus calls His followers to lay down their right to retaliation and trust God with justice—responding to wrong with humility, generosity, and grace.
Don’t Just Read the Bible — Understand It
My heart behind these commentaries is simple:
to help everyday believers grow confident in God’s Word.
If you’d like thoughtful, faithful Bible teaching delivered straight to your inbox, subscribe below.
We’ll walk through each book together — one passage at a time.
Leave a Reply