Should Christians Tithe Today? Series

Why the Apostles Never Command Christians to Tithe

If tithing was such an important part of life under the Old Testament, why do the apostles never simply tell the church, “Christians must tithe”? That question sits near the center of the modern debate. In this article, we will look at Acts, Paul, and the New Testament letters to see how apostolic teaching frames Christian giving after the resurrection, after Pentecost, and within the life of the church.

Tier 2 — The Biblical Overview

Why This Question Matters

If the apostles believed Christians were required to tithe, we would expect that teaching to appear clearly in the letters written to churches. After all, the apostles gave instruction on many practical matters: church leadership, the Lord’s Supper, marriage, discipline, giving, and care for the poor.

So when the New Testament never simply says, “Christians must tithe,” that silence matters. It does not end the conversation by itself, but it does force us to ask why.

1. Acts 15 and Gentile Believers

One of the most important passages is the Jerusalem Council in Acts 15:1–29. The early church had to answer a major question: Must Gentile believers keep the Law of Moses?

Some were saying yes. But the apostles did not place the full Mosaic covenant on Gentile converts. Instead, they gave a short list of instructions tied mainly to fellowship, idolatry, and holiness.

What is striking is what they did not command:

• circumcision
• full Sabbath observance
• festival keeping
• clean/unclean regulations in full
• tithing

2. Paul’s Actual Teaching on Giving

Paul talks often about money and generosity, but he does not command churches to tithe. Instead, he gives principles for Christian giving.

For example, in 1 Corinthians 16:1–2, Paul instructs believers:

That gives us several New Testament principles:

• regular giving — “on the first day of the week”
• personal participation — “each of you”
• proportionate giving — “in keeping with how he is prospering”

In 2 Corinthians 8–9, Paul goes even deeper. He teaches believers to give:

• graciously
• willingly
• cheerfully
• generously
• in response to Christ’s grace

Notice what Paul does not say: “Each person must tithe.” Instead, he gives a robust theology of generous stewardship shaped by the gospel.

3. Supporting Gospel Ministry Without a Tithe Command

The apostles clearly believed churches should support those who labor in ministry. Paul says:

Paul draws a principle from the Old Testament worship system: those who serve in God’s work should be supported. But he stops short of saying that the church must recreate the Levitical tithe system.

In other words, the apostles preserve the principle of supporting ministry without explicitly carrying over the Old Covenant mechanism of tithing.

Tier 3 — The Deeper Study

The Temple Was Still Standing When the Apostles Wrote

This point is often overlooked, but it is very important. Much of the New Testament was written before AD 70, when the Jerusalem temple was still standing.

That means the apostles were writing at a time when:

• the temple still functioned
• priests still served
• Jews who lived under the Mosaic system still recognized the tithe structure

So if the apostles believed the church should simply continue the tithe as a fixed requirement, they had every opportunity to say so while the temple was still operating. Yet even in that setting, they consistently teach giving in terms of generosity, willingness, partnership, and stewardship rather than a mandatory tenth.

Hebrews 7 and the Change in Priesthood

Another important passage is Hebrews 7. This chapter mentions tithing directly, but not in order to command Christians to tithe. Instead, it uses Abraham’s tithe to Melchizedek to make a larger argument about priesthood.

The crucial verse is:

Under the Old Covenant, the tithe was tightly bound to the Levitical priesthood. But under the New Covenant, Christ is the greater and final High Priest. That does not mean God’s people stop giving. It means the old covenant structure tied to temple and Levites is no longer the controlling framework.

The New Testament moves from:

• Levites supported by tithes
• to gospel workers supported by believers

And it does so without giving the church a direct command to tithe.

Why the Apostles Emphasize Principles Instead of Percentages

The church is not ancient Israel. It is not a nation-state with tribal land allotments, a central sanctuary, and a Levitical priesthood. It is a Spirit-filled people drawn from Jew and Gentile, scattered among the nations, supporting gospel ministry in a much broader mission context.

That helps explain why the apostles teach principles rather than simply restating the tithe law. Their framework includes:

• regular giving
• proportionate giving
• willing giving
• cheerful giving
• generous giving
• support for ministry
• care for the poor

In short, the apostles teach a richer New Covenant theology of giving rather than merely repeating an Old Covenant percentage.

This Does Not Mean the Apostles Opposed Tithing

It is important to be careful here. Saying the apostles never command Christians to tithe is not the same as saying the apostles thought tithing was wrong.

Many Christians may still choose to use 10% as a wise starting point or practical benchmark for generosity. The point is simply that the apostles do not present the tithe as a direct law binding the church in the way it functioned under Moses.

Why This Matters for the Tithing Debate Today

This helps explain why sincere Christians land in different places. Some see the tithe as a helpful and wise starting point for disciplined giving. Others argue that because the apostles never command it, the church should speak in terms of generous stewardship rather than a required 10%.

What should not be missed is this: the apostles did not reduce the importance of giving. They intensified it by rooting it in grace, mission, love, and care for others.

Next in This Series

If the apostles never explicitly command Christians to tithe, then the next question becomes very practical:

In the next article, we will bring the whole discussion together and look at the major views Christians hold, the strengths and weaknesses of each, and a balanced biblical conclusion for believers today.

Back to top ↑